Soundtrack

Principal Edwards Magic Theatre's first album (not an actual soundtrack; Soundtrack was just the title) was a fitfully inspired but exasperating of-its-time affair. The sprawling troupe, with more than ten musicians contributing to the record, was at its best when doing a form of British {folk-rock} with a wistful quasi-medieval air. That's best heard on the epic 13-minute The Death of Don Quixote, and also on Sacrifice, and Enigmatic Insomniac Machine. To drag in an obscure reference, at times they sound like a far more folk-oriented counterpart to the early-'70s British {art rock} band Julian's Treatment, another band with a haunting, female lead singer who made much of dramatic tunes with a faintly theatrical, fantastical, storytelling spin. However, the multi-sectioned, winding tunes require patience to sit through, and the mood is sometimes shot by the band's periodic shifts into lumpy {blues-rock}. Had the group been centered around Vivienne McAuliffe's strong quasi-Renaissance balladry vocals (and occasional Shakespearean narration) and their folkier material, they'd be a worthy footnote in British {folk-rock}. But both their songwriting and approach were too inconsistent for that, and when McAuliffe steps aside in favor of male vocals, the singing's far less memorable. ~ Richie Unterberger, All Music Guide